Elon Musk and Tesla have successfully won the dismissal of a $258 billion lawsuit that accused them of manipulating the price of Dogecoin through a series of tweets and public statements.
U.S. District Judge Alvin Hellerstein in Manhattan ruled on Thursday night that the claims brought by investors lacked sufficient grounds, labeling Musk’s tweets about Dogecoin as “aspirational and puffery” rather than factual statements that could be proven false.
This ruling effectively closes the case, preventing investors from re-filing the lawsuit in the future.
The lawsuit, originally filed in 2022, claimed that Musk and Tesla engaged in insider trading and market manipulation, alleging that they profited at the expense of Dogecoin investors.
The investors argued that Musk’s public endorsements and actions drove Dogecoin’s price up by more than 36,000% over two years, only for the price to plummet afterward.
Notably, they cited an instance in April 2023, where Musk replaced Twitter’s logo with the Dogecoin Shiba Inu logo, leading to a 30% spike in Dogecoin’s value before he allegedly sold off his holdings.
Judge’s Rationale: Aspirational Statements, Not Fraud
Judge Hellerstein’s ruling hinged on the nature of Musk’s public statements. He determined that Musk’s comments, including claims that Dogecoin could become the “future currency of Earth” or could be used to purchase Teslas, were exaggerated promotional statements rather than concrete facts.
The judge noted that no reasonable investor could rely on such hyperbolic statements to support a claim of securities fraud.
Furthermore, the judge dismissed the insider trading allegations, stating that the investors failed to provide concrete evidence linking Musk or Tesla to suspicious trading activities.
Despite the investors’ claims, the court found no substantial proof that Musk owned two wallets allegedly used for manipulative trades or that Tesla was involved in selling Dogecoin.
Implications and Reactions
The dismissal of this high-profile case marks a significant legal victory for Musk, who has frequently used his social media presence to influence public sentiment around cryptocurrencies and his companies. Musk’s lawyer, Alex Spiro, hailed the court’s decision, stating, “It’s a very good day for Dogecoin,” underscoring the defense’s argument that Musk’s tweets were harmless and did not constitute market manipulation.
The investors, who had revised their complaint four times over the course of two years, did not immediately respond to the court’s decision. Their original lawsuit sought $258 billion in damages, a figure that would have been unprecedented in cases of alleged cryptocurrency fraud.
Looking Ahead: The Case’s Broader Impact
The court’s decision to dismiss the lawsuit with prejudice means that the claims cannot be brought back to court, effectively ending the legal battle. The ruling may set a precedent for how courts handle similar cases in the future, particularly those involving high-profile individuals who use social media to comment on volatile markets like cryptocurrencies.
Musk, who purchased Twitter in October 2022 and rebranded it as X, remains one of the most influential figures in both the tech and financial worlds. As of now, he is worth approximately $239.3 billion, according to Forbes. This case serves as a reminder of the challenges investors face when attempting to hold public figures accountable for market fluctuations driven by social media activity.
Key Takeaways:
- Musk and Tesla won the dismissal of a $258 billion lawsuit over Dogecoin manipulation claims.
- The judge ruled Musk’s statements were “aspirational and puffery,” not factual.
- The case was dismissed with prejudice, preventing it from being re-filed.
As the cryptocurrency market continues to evolve, this ruling highlights the complexities of regulating and litigating in a space where public figures wield significant influence. Investors and legal experts alike will be watching closely to see how this case shapes future legal battles in the crypto world.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
See More
Join 350 000+ traders receiving Free Trading Signals
Alerts
Rates
Calendar
Signals
Top Broker