IRS’s New Ruling on Decentralized Exchanges: A Major Challenge for the Crypto Industry
The U.S. Internal Revenue Service (IRS) recently unveiled a ruling that requires decentralized exchanges (DEXs) to comply with the same reporting standards as traditional brokers.
This new regulation, set to be implemented in 2027, mandates brokers to report gross proceeds from digital asset transactions, including cryptocurrencies, stablecoins, and non-fungible tokens (NFTs). However, this expanded scope now includes front-end decentralized finance (DeFi) platforms, sparking widespread criticism from crypto executives, legal experts, and industry advocates.
Uniswap’s Response and Legal Concerns
The response from key figures in the crypto industry has been one of alarm. Katherine Minarik, Chief Legal Officer (CLO) of Uniswap, questioned the IRS’s rationale behind the ruling, highlighting that DeFi platforms play a different role than traditional brokers.
According to Minarik, these platforms are only part of the transaction process and should not be classified as brokers. Her concerns were shared by Uniswap’s CEO, Hayden Adams, who expressed hopes that the ruling would be overturned either through legal challenges or the Congressional Review Act (CRA).
In her December 27 post on X, Minarik called for a challenge to the ruling, emphasizing that the decentralized nature of these platforms does not align with the IRS’s reporting requirements. This view was echoed by Adams, who hopes that a legal challenge will lead to a favorable outcome for the industry.
Operational and Technical Challenges for Decentralized Platforms
Critics of the IRS’s new regulations argue that the decentralized nature of DEXs makes it nearly impossible for these platforms to adhere to traditional reporting standards. Robin Singh, CEO of crypto tax platform Koinly, warned that the compliance burden would be particularly challenging for decentralized businesses. The infrastructure required for conventional reporting, such as tracking individual user transactions and generating tax forms, does not exist within the decentralized ecosystem.
Unlike centralized exchanges, which can track users and provide tax forms, DeFi platforms typically lack such centralized control, making it difficult to meet the IRS’s requirements. Singh pointed out that the reporting obligations imposed by the IRS could lead to significant operational and technical hurdles, further complicating the regulatory landscape for DEXs.
Legal and Legislative Pushback
Legal experts and crypto veterans have also voiced their opposition to the IRS ruling. Bill Hughes, a lawyer at blockchain development firm Consensys, called the ruling “all cost, no benefit,” criticizing the global reach of the regulation, which mandates reporting for both U.S. and international users. He predicted that the ruling would face significant opposition and could be overturned through Congressional review or legal challenges.
Jake Chervinsky, Chief Legal Officer at venture capital firm Variant, went a step further, calling the ruling an “unlawful” measure pushed by the outgoing administration’s “anti-crypto army.” He speculated that the regulation could be reversed by the courts or a new administration, reflecting the growing frustration with what many perceive as an overreach by regulators.
Advocacy Groups and Calls for Congressional Action
The Blockchain Association, a prominent advocacy group in the crypto space, has voiced strong opposition to the ruling, arguing that it could lead to the U.S. losing its competitive edge in the global crypto industry. The association contends that this move is part of a broader effort to drive the U.S. crypto industry offshore, pushing innovation and development into more crypto-friendly jurisdictions.
Kristin Smith, CEO of the Blockchain Association, emphasized the need for policymakers to reconsider the implications of this ruling. The association is prepared to take aggressive action to challenge the regulations and work with the new, pro-crypto Congress and administration to roll back these and other regulations that hinder innovation.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
See More
Join 350 000+ traders receiving Free Trading Signals
Alerts
Rates
Calendar
Signals
Top Broker